for_the_wookie

but we have satellites the bring wireless technology right to my doorstep—?

why would I want a shitty ass tech that requires nodes almost ever 100ft?

buzzing around my head all day is bad enough!

djsumdog

You realize you get nothing by satellite right? Satellite lag is high and bandwidth is very limited. Almost all transcontinental communications come via undersea cables. No one has successfully launched a low-orbit Internet satellite system yet, and even if someone does, it will pale in comparison to direct fiber to the home.

for_the_wookie

/sarcasm

satellites.... hahahaha

riiiiigghhhttt ;)

scarlettm512

Of course. If you nationalize it, people won't be able to sue corporations when they realize that cancer clusters pop up around these things. Quite a brilliant strategy to transfer the liability to the American taxpayer (I'm sure we'll have something akin to those vaccine injury funds available for victims) while simultaneously convincing them that you are looking out for them.

fl3x

I'd much rather have a nationalized fiber network.

Cell phones deserve the same warning labels cigarettes have:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ludhja7sW0I

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=T1FYsdC7krs

Beyond being focused death rays, there are a number of issues: wireless is inherently insecure so if it were developed for use as home internet, a line underground would still be superior (build a fiber grid). What am I supposed to use as a base-station anyway? A $1000 iPhone that I have to replace every few years because they stop supporting it? Sure, if it's subsidized (a waste of money). A device similar to my dsl/cable modem? ...that piece of shit gets patched once a year if I'm lucky. If 5G is going to be as pervasive as people are wanting it to be, you can bet your last dollar that there are going to be people working to break it and pwn your devices. Wireless is insecure. It causes cancer. Never use it. 5G = focused death rays.

Percal

The main problems I can see underground fiber having are flooding, rodents/insects, and earthquakes. I imagine it would also be inconvenient to have dig up cable to for maintenance and repairs.

fl3x

Underground is really not as bad as it may seem, and the fiber doesn't necessarily have to go underground. Even if it did, gas, water, sewage, and some electric goes underground as well. With earthquakes it really just depends on their scale. Some places in North America only experience tremors that are picked up only by seismometers.

In places like California it's still manageable; Musk wants to build underground transportation tunnels there for cars.

475677

Take a lesson from the failure that is the National Broadband Network in Australia and actually build the fucking network at the national level using the best available technology and then lease access to private organizations as a wholesale provider. From there it's up to the private companies to provide enough bandwidth to the customers they group together to achieve full speed and since that can mean lower speeds for lower prices it also means higher prices for higher quality service. It's about as free and fair as you can make it while keeping everything standardized unlike the cable/fiber/copper/satellite bullshit we have here which will have to be totally rebuilt in the long term so do it right the first time and avoid our fate.

carlip

this is completely retarded

KikeFree

Instead, what he should do is have a large chunk of spectrum opened up to unlicensed public use. People will make their own networks.

exi1ed0ne

Ditto. The current unlicensed spectrum in the US is pure crap.

freeterrydavis17

As a base option, could be a good idea as internet is a must have infrastructure these days. However, cellular frequencies should be public domain to allow for private local internets without the need for wired infrastructure. As long as there's a government board deciding who can offer internet access there's an issue.

gazillions

There's probably as many reasons for as there are against.

Ho-Lee-Fuk

I'm down with this actually.